The Monacan in Virginia

John Smith located five Monacan villages in the Piedmont upstream of the Fall Line of the James River: Monahassanugh, Rassawek, Mowhemencho, Monassukapanough, and Massinacack
John Smith located five Monacan villages in the Piedmont upstream of the Fall Line of the James River: Monahassanugh, Rassawek, Mowhemencho, Monassukapanough, and Massinacack
Source: Library of Congress, Virginia (by John Smith, 1624)

When the English colonists arrived in 1607, the Monacan were both traders with - and rivals of - paramount chief Powhatan.

The Monacans were a Siouan-speaking group who lived west of the Fall Line. In contrast, every one of the tribes controlled by Powhatan in the territory he controlled east of the Fall Line, which was known as Tsenacommacah, spoke an Algonquian language.

Siouan speakers may have migrated into Virginia across the Allegheny Mountains from the Ohio River valley, via the Big Sandy River or Kanawha drainages, 4,000 years ago. According to a modern scholar, the name of the Monacans could be derived from the word "mani." It meant "water" in the Siouan language spoken by the Tutelo, who lived west of the Monacan territory on the Piedmont and in the Blue Ridge.

John Smith recorded the tribe's name at least five ways: Monacans, Massinnacacks, Russawmeake, Monahassanuggs, and Mouhemenchughes.

The distinction between Monacan, Tutelo, and Saponi may reflect an artificial perspective of colonists; the three groups could have been part of a common culture occupying the Piedmont from the Roanoke River north to near the Rapidan River. The Monacan call themselves "Yesan," for "the people."1

The English learned that the Monacan existed west of Tsenacommacah on May 24, 1607. They then wanted to meet with them, in hopes of discovering gold/silver comparable to what the Spanish found in Mexico and Peru. They also wanted to meet Powhatan's enemies, in hopes of gaining some leverage over the paramount chief who controlled their food supply at Jamestown. For that same reason, Powhatan's people blocked the initial plans of the English to travel upriver.

John Smith gained the next intelligence about the Monacans in August, 1608. He captured a Siouian-speaking Native American, Amoroleck, after traveling up the Rappahannock River to the area of modern-day Fones Cliff. Through an interpreter, Smith learned the Monacans lived in the hilly country alongside rivers, and relied primarily upon hunting for food.

In September 1608, Captain Christopher Newport led an expedition past the Fall Line of the James River. He intended to meet with the Monacans, despite Powhatan's objections. They may have gone as much as 40 miles upriver in two and a half days, and reached the towns of Monhemenchouch and Massinacak, 14 miles futher west at the confluence of James and Mohawk Creek (called Mahock Creek by John Lederer in 1670). Today, those sites are located in the inappropriately-named Powhatan County.

The English found no gold or silver. They turned back downstream before reaching the Monacan's primary town of Rassawek at the confluence of the Rivanna and James rivers, or Monasukapanough further up the Rivanna at modern-day Charlottesville.2

in 1608 Christopher Newport may have reached the Monacan town of Massinacak, just downstream from modern Powhatan State Park
in 1608 Christopher Newport may have reached the Monacan town of Massinacak, just downstream from modern Powhatan State Park
Source: North Carolina Maps, ArcGIS Online

John Smith mapped the locations of five Monacan towns, based on interviews with various Native Americans that he encountered. His Maltese cross indicates that he traveled only to the Fall Line of the James River, perhaps reaching the site of the modern Huguenot Bridge.

English familiarity with the Monacans remained limited throughout the 1600's. John Lederer passed through their territory on his second journey to the Blue Ridge in 1670. He recorded the continued presence of Monhemenchouch and Massinacak.

John Lederer visited the two Monacan towns closest to the Fall Line in 1670
John Lederer visited the two Monacan towns closest to the Fall Line in 1670
Source: University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, The Discoveries of John Lederer (1672)

When John Ogilby sketched the possible North Carolina-Virginia border to a speculative location near the mouth of the Rivanna River in 1671, he documented only two Monacan towns which he called Monakin and Mahock. His map may have reflected just European unfamiliarity with the territory controlled by the Monacans, but the absence of other towns could also reflect population decline in the Piedmont.

a 1671 map showed only two Monacan towns
a 1671 map showed only two Monacan towns
Source: North Carolina Maps, A new discription of Carolina by the order of the Lords Proprietors (John Ogilby, ~1671)

Permanent towns in the eastern part of the Monacan territory were abandoned between 1670-1690. Most likely, the residents moved west to live closer to the mountains, including with the Tutelo/Saponi.

Mowhemencho was still visited regularly by the Monacans in 1702, when the site was called Manakin Town by the Huguenots who had settled there in 1699. Franz Louis Michel recorded:3

The Indians often visit there, bringing game, rum and other small things. There is a good opportunity to trade with skins. They (the Indians) often bring pottery and when desired fill'd with corn.

Before the Monacan tribe evolved, their territory had been occupied earlier by a culture which shared a key characteristic with Native Americans in the Mississippi River Valley: burying the dead in mounds. The Monacans may have continued that practice, unlike the Algonquian-speaking tribes east of the Fall Line which the English encountered, or they may have just venerated the old mounds while burying their dead elsewhere.

In the early 1700's, Native Americans crossing the Rivanna River reportedly stopped to pay respects at the ancient burial mound at the former site of Monasukapanough. The visitors may have been Cherokee, Catawba, or members of another tribe passing through rather than Monacans still living in the local area.

Thomas Jefferson excavated that mound in the 1780's as he was writing Notes on the State of Virginia. By 1911, when another archeologist excavated there, the Rivanna River mound had been flattened by plowing, soil removal, and flooding.4

English colonists began to occupy the area now within Albemarle County in the 1720's; the county itself was formed in 1744. By the time settlers arrived at the base of the Blue Ridge, the Monacan towns along major rivers had been abandoned. Though many of the Monacans joined with the Tutelo, Saponi, and other Siouan-speaking tribes, they never completely left the James River watershed. Instead, the people retreated into the valleys within the Blue Ridge to avoid conflict with rival Native Americans and later the settlers.

The Monacan lost control of the Piedmont before English settlers arrived. The warring Iroquois, Cherokee, and Catawba were more powerful, and their raids through Virginia in the 1600's affected the original inhabitants of Virginia as well as the later-arriving colonists.

The Haudenosaunee Confederacy (Iroquois) defeated rival tribes to the north and west during the Beaver Wars of the 1640's and 1650's. In the 1670's, they seized control over the Susquehannock and Nanticoke to the south in Maryland and what became Pennsylvania/Delaware. Display of fighting capacity and "mourning wars" were critical components in the Iroquois culture, and the five tribes based in New York expanded their raids further south to fight the Catawba and Cherokee. The Siouan-speaking tribes on the Piedmont of Virginia such as the Monacan, Tutelo and Saponi were disrupted and displaced by other Native Americans before colonial settlers arrived in large numbers.5

Though the Monacan towns were no longer occupied, Monacan people blended into the ridges and valleys in Albemarle, Nelson, and Amherst counties. They lived on the fringe of "American" society, intermarrying with enslaved people who escaped as well as white settlers. An archeologist who excavated the Rivanna (Jefferson) Mound in 1911 reported:6

At the present time there are living along the foot of the Blue Ridge, in Amherst, a number of families who possess Indian features and other characteristics of the aborigines. Their language contains many Indian words... While these people may represent the last remnants of various tribes, still it is highly probable that among them are living the last of the Monacan.

The territory controlled by the Monacan when colonists arrived include two burial mounds built originally during the Mississippian culture time period. Construction of the Rivanna (Jefferson) Mound in the headwaters of the Rivanna River and the Rapidan Mound in the headwaters of the Rapidan River started before 1400CE (Common Era). The Monacans may have continued to use those burial mounds as ceremonial sites, spiritual places, or even for their own burials. Removal of the top portions makes it impossible to date their last use.7

The population of the Monacan/Tutelo/Saponi/Occaneechi and other closely-related tribes may have totalled 10,000-20,000 people before European contact. At the start of the 21st Century, Monacan Chief Kenneth Branham estimated that the Monacan population had dropped to around 500 people in the middle of the 1700's. Most lived in the mountains in Amherst County, especially Bear Mountain.7

In 1908, the Episcopal denomination started Saint Paul's Mission and the Bear Mountain Indian Mission School. Those facilities became the focal point of their community. The church was destroyed by fire in 1930, but quickly rebuilt. The school was segregated so only Monacans attended. The Monacans were educated through the seventh grade in that one school until public schools were integrated in 1963.

The state granted official recognition to the tribe on February 14, 1989.

The Episcopal Church donated their claims to the mission property back to the Monacans in 1995, retaining ownership of just the church building and a structure for the caretakers. The tribe has restored the log cabin, built around 1868 and used as a church, so it is now a tribal museum.

Today the tribe is officially the Monacan Indian Nation, Inc., incorporated as a nonprofit 501(c)3 organization. There are about 2,100 members, with around 500 living in Amherst County.

The 12 members on the Tribal Council are elected for four-year terms. Membership in the tribe, including the right to vote in elections, is based on descent from someone listed on the "original rolls" that were compiled from genealogical data and oral histories in the 1980's and 1990's.8

Federal government recognition occurred on January 29, 2018, when President Trump signed the Thomasina E. Jordan Indian Tribes of Virginia Federal Recognition Act. The tribe chose to get Federal recognition through a law passed by the US Congress, rather than through the administrative procedures followed by the Pamunkey. Records documenting the continued existence of the Monacans since the 1600's were sparse, in part because the Commonwealth of Virginia had sought after 1924 to declare that there were no Native Americans in Virginia and everyone must be classified as "white" or "colored."

One impact of choosing the legislative route to recognition is that the Monacans are not eligble to operate any gambling facilities on their land, even if it were to be taken into trust by the US Department of the Interior. The land owned by the the Monacan Indian Nation, Inc. is private property. It is not held in trust by the Federal government like Native American reservations in western states. It is not held in trust by the Commonwealth of Virginia either, as are the reservations of the Pamunkey and Mattaponi.9

Preservation of Monican heritage is still an ongoing issue. The site of Rassawek, at the mouth of the Rivanna River, was damaged by construction of a natural gas pipeline in the 1980's. Remnants could be altered by plans of the James River Water Authority (JRWA) to build a water pump station there, at "Point of Fork" next to the former town of Columbia. The growth plans are based upon transporting water from the James River for Louisa and Fluvanna counties to develop Zion Crossroads.10

Burial Mounds in Virginia

Rassawek

Re-creation of Monacan Town

Links

the log cabin schoolhouse and chapel at Bear Mountain
the log cabin schoolhouse and chapel at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Amherst Indian School and Mission: Falling Rock (by Jackson Davis, 1915)

teacher's cabin at Bear Mountain
teacher's cabin at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Amherst Indian School Chapel and Teachers Cottage (by Jackson Davis, 1914)

students at Bear Mountain
students at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Amherst: Group of Students. Indian Mission School (by Jackson Davis, 1914)

inside the schoolhouse at Bear Mountain
inside the schoolhouse at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Group of Students Indian Mission School, Falling Rock (by Jackson Davis, between 1914-1947)

inside the schoolhouse at Bear Mountain
inside the schoolhouse at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Indian Mission School, Falling Rock (by Jackson Davis, between 1914-1947)

students at Bear Mountain
students at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Group of students Indian Mission, Falling Rock (by Jackson Davis, 1914)

students at Bear Mountain
students at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Group of Students Indian Mission, Falling Rock, Recess Time (by Jackson Davis, 1914)

log cabin home at Bear Mountain
log cabin home at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Amherst Indian Settlement, Falling Rock. Log Cabin (by Jackson Davis, between 1914-1947)

grandmother in cabin at Bear Mountain
grandmother in cabin at Bear Mountain
Source: Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Old Woman in Door of Log Cabin. Indian Settlement. Grandmother of 48 (by Jackson Davis, between 1915-1947)

References

1. Karenne Wood, "'The Language Ghost': Linguistic Heritage and Collective Identity Among the Monacan Indians of Central Virginia," PhD thesis at University of Virginia, May 2016, p.3, pp.24-28, https://libraetd.lib.virginia.edu/downloads/4t64gn57f?filename=Wood_Language_Ghost_Dissertation_Final_Copy.pdf; David I. Bushnell Jr., The Five Monacan Towns in Virginia, 1607, Smithsonian Institution, 1930, p.4, https://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/001677874 (last checked July 8, 2019)
2. "Monacan Indian Nation," Encyclopedia Virginia, Virginia Foundation for the Humanities, March 11, 2019, https://www.encyclopediavirginia.org/Monacan_Indian_Nation; Jeffrey L. Hantman, "Between Powhatan and Quirank: Reconstructing Monacan Culture and History in the Context of Jamestown," American Anthropologist, New Series, Volume 92, Number 3 (September, 1990), https://www.jstor.org/stable/680342; Karenne Wood, "'The Language Ghost': Linguistic Heritage and Collective Identity Among the Monacan Indians of Central Virginia," PhD thesis at University of Virginia, May 2016, p.30, https://libraetd.lib.virginia.edu/downloads/4t64gn57f?filename=Wood_Language_Ghost_Dissertation_Final_Copy.pdf (last checked June 10, 2019)
3. David I. Bushnell Jr., The Five Monacan Towns in Virginia, 1607, Smithsonian Institution, 1930, p.9, https://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/001677874; James Mooney, The Siouan Tribes of the East, Smithsonian Institution, 1894, p.30, https://books.google.com/books?id=BYne-EO4YYYC (last checked July 8, 2019)
4. "University of Virginia Academical Village: Cultural Landscape Report Part 1," Office of the Architect, University of Virginia, September 2013, p.27, http://www.officearchitect.virginia.edu/pdfs/CLRFullDec2013.pdf; Jeffrey Hantman, "Jefferson's Mound Archaeological Site," Encyclopedia Virginia, Virginia Foundation for the Humanities, November 22, 2016, https://www.encyclopediavirginia.org/Jefferson_s_Mound_Archaeological_Site; David I. Bushnell, Jr., The William and Mary Quarterly, Volume 23, Number 2 (October, 1914), pp.109-112, https://www.jstor.org/stable/1915110 (last checked June 14, 2019)
5. Zach Parrott, "Iroquois Wars," The Canadian Encyclopedia, March 4, 2015, https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/iroquois-wars; Daniel K. Richter, "War and Culture: The Iroquois Experience," William and Mary Quarterly, Volume 40, Number 4 (October, 1983), pp.530-531, https://www.jstor.org/stable/1921807 (last checked June 15, 2019)
6. David I. Bushnell, Jr., The William and Mary Quarterly, Volume 23, Number 2 (October, 1914), pp.109-112, https://www.jstor.org/stable/1915110 (last checked June 14, 2019)
7. Gary Dunham, Debra Gold, Jeffrey Hantman, "Collective Burial in Late Prehistoric Virginia: Excavation and Analysis of the Rapidan Mound," American Antiquity, Volume 68, Number 1 (January, 2003), p.110, p.118, p.121, https://www.jstor.org/stable/3557035; Jeffrey L. Hantman, Debra L. Gold and Gary H. Dunham, "Of Parsimony and Archaeological Histories: A Response to Comment by Boyd," American Antiquity, Volume 69, Number 3 (July, 2004), https://www.jstor.org/stable/4128408; Karenne Wood, "'The Language Ghost': Linguistic Heritage and Collective Identity Among the Monacan Indians of Central Virginia," PhD thesis at University of Virginia, May 2016, p.29, pp.158-159, https://libraetd.lib.virginia.edu/downloads/4t64gn57f?filename=Wood_Language_Ghost_Dissertation_Final_Copy.pdf (last checked June 27, 2019)
8. Karenne Wood, "'The Language Ghost': Linguistic Heritage and Collective Identity Among the Monacan Indians of Central Virginia," PhD thesis at University of Virginia, May 2016, p.29, pp.158-159, https://libraetd.lib.virginia.edu/downloads/4t64gn57f?filename=Wood_Language_Ghost_Dissertation_Final_Copy.pdf; "The Monacan Nation," Elder Wisdom with Barbara Roberts, Virginia Indian Archive, http://www.virginiaindianarchive.org/items/show/109; "Virginia's Monacan tribe uses new federal status to take a stand for what could be its long-lost capital," Washington Post, January 5, 2020, https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/virginia-politics/virginias-monacan-tribe-uses-new-federal-status-to-take-a-stand-for-what-could-be-its-long-lost-capital/2020/01/05/66a6f826-227f-11ea-bed5-880264cc91a9_story.html (last checked January 7, 2020)
9. "Monacan Indian Nation" Encyclopedia Virginia, Virginia Foundation for the Humanities, March 11, 2019, https://www.encyclopediavirginia.org/Monacan_Indian_Nation (last checked June 21, 2019)
10. Karenne Wood, "'The Language Ghost': Linguistic Heritage and Collective Identity Among the Monacan Indians of Central Virginia," PhD thesis at University of Virginia, May 2016, p.30, https://libraetd.lib.virginia.edu/downloads/4t64gn57f?filename=Wood_Language_Ghost_Dissertation_Final_Copy.pdf; "Zion Crossroads housing plans stalled, for now," Central Virginian, June 20, 2019, http://www.thecentralvirginian.com/zion-crossroads-housing-plans-stalled-for-now-2/ (last checked June 21, 2019)
11. "Comments of the Monacan Indian Nation on the Revised Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) and Treatment Plan for Architectural Resources 032-0036 and 032-5124, and Archeological Sites 44FV0022, 44FV0024, and 44FV0268, associated with the James River Water Supply Pump Station and Pipeline Alignment," letter from Monacan Indian Nation attorney to Steven VanderPloeg, US Army Corps of Engineers, June 5, 2019, http://www.culturalheritagepartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Monacan_MOA_Comments_6_5-2019_Final_Submitted-1.pdf; "The Monacan Indian Nation Urges You To Help Save Rassawek," Cultural Heritage Partners (law firm for the Monacan Nation), http://www.culturalheritagepartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/SaveRassawek_8_12_2019.pdf (last checked August 16, 2019)
12. "Comments of the Monacan Indian Nation on the Revised Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) and Treatment Plan for Architectural Resources 032-0036 and 032-5124, and Archeological Sites 44FV0022, 44FV0024, and 44FV0268, associated with the James River Water Supply Pump Station and Pipeline Alignment," letter from Monacan Indian Nation attorney to Steven VanderPloeg, US Army Corps of Engineers, June 5, 2019, http://www.culturalheritagepartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Monacan_MOA_Comments_6_5-2019_Final_Submitted-1.pdf; "Monacan Indian Nation's Objection to the James River Water Authority's Application for the Removal and Temporary Curation of Human Remains Located at Point of Fork, Fluvanna County, Virginia, DHR File No. 2015-0984," letter from Monacan Indian Nation attorney to Julie Langan, Director Virginia Department of Historic Resources, July 23, 2019, http://www.culturalheritagepartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Monacan-Ltr-to-DHR_7_23_2019_final_2-1.pdf (last checked August 16, 2019)


Native American Tribes in Virginia Since Contact
"Indians" of Virginia - the Real First Families of Virginia
Exploring Land, Settling Frontiers
Virginia Places