Cobbs Creek Reservoir

Cobbs Creek in Cumberland County was dammed to form a new drinking water reservoir for Henrico, Powhatan, Goochland and Cumberland counties
Cobbs Creek in Cumberland County was dammed to form a new drinking water reservoir for Henrico, Powhatan, Goochland and Cumberland counties
Cobbs Creek in Cumberland County was dammed to form a new drinking water reservoir for Henrico, Powhatan, Goochland and Cumberland counties
Source: US Geological Survey (USGS), Lakeside Village 1:24,000 scale topographic map (2013, Revision 1); Lakeside Village 1:24,000 scale topographic map (2022)

After the 2002 drought, the state required all localities to develop long-range water supply plans. Cumberland County started planning a new reservoir on Cobbs Creek in Cumberland County, then arranged with Henrico County to purchase the land and build the new water storage system. Powhatan County and Goochland County were also recruited to share costs and water, so Cobbs Creek Reservoir became a regional water supply project led by Henrico County.

Henrico County formally announced the official name, the Virgil R. Hazelett Reservoir at Cobbs Creek, in 2024. Hazelett had been County Manager between 1992-2013, and instrumental in planning the new water supply source.

To create the reservoir, three dams were built to block flow of Cobbs Creek. Flow from the creek could not fill the reservoir; rainfall flowing downstream in the small watershed behind the dams was not be sufficient to provide a reliable water source. To fill the reservoir, water from the James River is pumped uphill and released behind the dam. To minimize environmental impacts, pumping is done when the James River is at high flow during the winter.

a 3,850-foot long, 160' tall earthen dam (shown in green) was built across Cobbs Creek, plus one 35' high dam to block potential overflow on the western edge
a 3,850-foot long, 160' tall earthen dam (shown in green) was built across Cobbs Creek, plus one 35' high dam to block potential overflow on the western edge
a 3,850-foot long, 160' tall earthen dam (shown in green) was built across Cobbs Creek, plus one 35' high dam to block potential overflow on the western edge
a 3,850-foot long, 160' tall earthen dam (shown in green) was built across Cobbs Creek, plus one 35' high dam to block potential overflow on the western edge
a 3,850-foot long, 160' tall earthen dam (shown in green) was built across Cobbs Creek, plus one 35' high dam to block potential overflow on the western edge
Source: Henrico County, Cobbs Creek Reservoir Map; ESRI, ArcgGIS Online; Henrico County, Facebook post (May 8, 2025)

Construction of the dam, water intake structure in the James River, pumping station, and other facilities were completed in 2024. Pumping of James River water into the reservoir started on June 11, 2024. By May 2025, the 1,117-acre reservoir was full and provided a 14.8-billion-gallon regional water supply.1

pumping began on June 11, 2024 and the reservoir was full in May, 2025
pumping began on June 11, 2024 and the reservoir was full in May, 2025
pumping began on June 11, 2024 and the reservoir was full in May, 2025
Source: Henrico County, Facebook post (May 8, 2025)

A larger dam on the James River itself, creating a new lake on the main stem, would provide more water storage - but a new dam blocking the primary channel of a major river is no longer a viable option. Such a dam would flood wetlands, farmland, and historical resources, as well as interfere with fish migration. Tapping the James River only at high flow times will ensure that withdrawals will not reduce water flow below the minimums required for fish during periods of drought.

Henrico County planned no water treatment plant at the Cobbs Creek Reservoir, and did not build a pipeline to deliver reservoir water to the county's existing water treatment plant. Instead, Henrico County planned to release water from the reservoir into the James River during periods of high demand. That water will augment the natural flow in the James River and provide wildlife benefits. The natural river channel was used rather than building a long concrete/steel pipeline.

the pumping structure and reservoir at full pool in 2026
the pumping structure and reservoir at full pool in 2026
Source: Henrico County, Reservoir Live Camera

The Department of Environmental Quality authorized withdrawal of 47 million gallons/day from the James River to fill the reservoir.

Henrico was permitted to withdraw up to 30 million gallons/day at its raw water intake near Boshers Dam. Henrico County already had permission to withdraw 45 million gallons per day for its drinking water treatment plant on Three Chopt Road near Gaskins Road through 2060. With the water to be released from the new reservoir, the county would be able to withdraw 75 million gallons/day from the James River.

In addition, the county had contracted with the City of Richmond to purchase 35 million gallons per day through 2040. Henrico County was planning ahead for substantial growth when it approved the reservoir, as well as the day when it might not be able to purchase water from Richmond.

Cumberland County was authorized to withdraw up to 7 million gallons/day. In 2026, the county's Board of Supervisors committed 2 million gallons/day from the reservoir to support Dominion's Energy's proposed natural gas plant. The 3,000 megawatt Cumberland Energy Center, if approved by state officials and constructed as planned by 2034, would be the second largest natural gas plant in the United States.

Powhatan County has the option to withdraw up to 10 million gallons/day. Withdrawal sites will be determined later by those two counties. The Cumberland Energy Center would be located upstream of the reservoir off Duncan Store Road. Dominion Energy was expected to pump its 2 million gallons/day from the western side of the reservoir through a pipeline to the natural gas power plant.

The project involved Henrico County purchasing 1,830 acres in Cumberland County, converting private land to tax-exempt public land. To replace the property taxes, Henrico County committed to pay $1.13 million annually to Cumberland County.

Building an off-stream storage reservoir, and pumping water into it at times of high flow, avoided many environmental impacts that would have been associated with pumping water in the summer. Sending water downstream to its drinking water treatment plant enabled Henrico County to supplement flow in the James River in times of drought, mitigating the impact of its project.

The Henrico County Public Utilities Director said:2

DEQ would not have simply granted a new permit to withdraw more water to accommodate future growth... Henrico had to do something to offset the future water withdrawals, and building a reservoir was our best option.

Cobbs Creek, at the location for the reservoir, was a small stream in Cumberland County
Cobbs Creek, at the location for the reservoir, was a small stream in Cumberland County
Source: Virginia Section: American Water Works Association 2011 conference, Reservoir Development for Sustainable River Management - Cobbs Creek Reservoir

Combining the requirements from multiple counties resulted in one large 1,117-acre reservoir ("one of the largest, if not the largest, municipally owned reservoir in Virginia") that flooded 31 acres of wetlands and 15 miles of streams. If separate jurisdictions had chosen to build multiple small reservoirs on different tributary streams, riparian zones on multiple streams would have been impacted.

The wetlands and riparian zone of Cobbs Creek were drowned by the new reservoir. Consolidating requirements resulted in a higher dam and larger reservoir that flooded more acres of upland forests, rather than multiple strips of wetlands and riparian areas on more James River tributaries.3

The mitigation strategy required of the counties was controversial because 75% of it was based on adding additional legal protection to streams in Cumberland State Forest. That state-owned forest was already being managed to meet environmental objectives. The benefits of protecting streams in the state forest rather than new streams on private land were questioned.

The counties claimed they were offsetting the impacts of flooding the Cobbs Creek watershed by putting $9.8 million into a Virginia Department of Forestry stream mitigation fund, and highlighted that the state forest was not required by the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act to maintain 100-foot riparian buffers. Cumberland State Forest is located in Cumberland County, outside the Tidewater counties subject to the act, but for over 50 years the state has maintained protected buffers in the forest twice the width required for reservoir mitigation.

building the Cobbs Creek Reservoir required relocating oil pipelines and electrical transmission lines, as well as clearing forested land
building the Cobbs Creek Reservoir required relocating oil pipelines and electrical transmission lines, as well as clearing forested land
Source: Cumberland County Online GIS System

Owners of private wetland mitigation banks had hoped that mitigation would require the counties to purchase "credits," which were available from the creation of new wetlands and preservation of other streams. Henrico County did purchase credits for the project's 31 acres of wetland impacts and 25% of the required stream preservation credits, but prohibited bidders from publicly opposing the mitigation plan.

A member of the House of Delegates from Cumberland County stated his opposition clearly:4

While I support the reservoir project and agree that it is an important water supply development for Henrico County, I remain concerned that its reliance on an unprecedented and highly questionable mitigation scheme, using mitigation credits of dubious value derived from state forest property, is unwise.

No site for a water reservoir is "perfect." Flooding the Cobbs Creek watershed required relocating existing high-voltage electrical transmission powerlines. Relocation was also required for 32 and 36 inch pipelines. Those two Colonial pipelines transported over 100 million gallons/day of refined petroleum products from refineries on the Gulf Coast to customers in Maryland and near New York City. Relocation costs for utility infrastructure exceeded $50 million, a substantial percentage of the projected $280 million cost.5

Cumberland County

Drinking Water in Virginia

Off-Stream Storage Reservoirs

Links

planned Cobbs Creek Reservoir, in Cumberland County
planned Cobbs Creek Reservoir, in Cumberland County
Source: Reservoir Development for Sustainable River Management - Cobbs Creek Reservoir

References

1. "New reservoir a decade away for Henrico, but work is fast-paced," Richmond Times-Dispatch, July 15, 2012, http://www.timesdispatch.com/news/new-reservoir-a-decade-away-for-henrico-but-work-is/article_a3f1c1c8-0918-5b89-bd9d-251d5cff1d8b.html; "Virginia Water Supply Snapshot: Progress Report on Cobbs Creek Reservoir Project in Cumberland County," Virginia Water Central News Grouper, July 25, 2012, https://vawatercentralnewsgrouper.wordpress.com/2012/07/25/virginia-water-supply-snapshot-progess-report-on-cobbs-creek-reservoir-project-in-cumberland-county/; "Henrico brings Cumberland County reservoir into the fold," Virginia Public Media, November 13, 2024, https://www.vpm.org/news/2024-11-13/henrico-county-cobbs-creek-virgil-hazelett-reservoir/; "Cobbs Creek Reservoir," Henrico County, https://henrico.gov/projects/cobbs-creek-reservoir/; Facebook post, Henrico County, May 8, 2025, https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1E4omM1UKy/ (last checked October 26, 2026)
2. "Cobbs Creek Reservoir Project," Cumberland County, http://www.coastals.org/forum/download.php?id=1487&sid=27bad5f6bebbbd67d63f3a656dc090c4; "Construction to begin on Cobbs Creek Reservoir," Henrico Today, Volume 18, Number 2 (Spring 2015), https://henrico.gov/assets/HT_Spring_2015.pdf; "In Cumberland, questions swirl over water sources for newly-approved Dominion gas plant," Virginia Mercury, October 26, 2026, https://virginiamercury.com/2026/10/26/in-cumberland-questions-remain-over-water-sources-for-a-dominion-gas-plant-supervisors-just-approved/ (last checked October 26, 2026)
3. "State water board approves disputed offset plan for Cobbs Creek Reservoir," Richmond Times-Dispatch, June 18, 2013, http://www.timesdispatch.com/news/local/henrico/state-water-board-approves-disputed-offset-plan-for-cobbs-creek/article_b28cca1f-554b-53c1-ad78-0fa4be853c4f.html; "Henrico County PUD Cobbs Creek Reservoir," Energy and Infrastructure, http://www.energyandinfrastructure.com/index.php/sections/profiles1?start=8 (last checked February 9, 2015)
4. "Report on Stream and Wetland Mitigation Proposals and Plans for the Henrico County Cobbs Creek Reservoir," National Mitigation Banking Association, August 28, 2012, www.mitigationbanking.org/pdfs/cobbscreekreport.pdf; "State water board approves disputed offset plan for Cobbs Creek Reservoir," Richmond Times-Dispatch, June 18, 2013, http://www.richmond.com/news/local/henrico/article_b28cca1f-554b-53c1-ad78-0fa4be853c4f.html (last checked October 31, 2013)
5. "Pipeline to closely skirt giant Henrico reservoir," Richmond Times-Dispatch, February 8, 2015, http://www.richmond.com/news/local/henrico/article_273e1f1f-35f8-5ed1-8594-54f39fef515d.html (last checked February 9, 2015)

Cobbs Creek watershed before the reservoir
Cobbs Creek watershed before the reservoir
Source: ESRI, ArcGIS Online


Rivers and Watersheds in Virginia
Virginia Places